What's a blueberry muffin throwdown, you ask. It is inspired by Bobby Flay's show, Throwdown, where he studies someone's signature dish, perfects it, then shows up to challenge them in a competition. I'm taking two blueberry muffin recipes, comparing them side by side, and selecting a winner based on which embodies the spirit, if you will, of a blueberry muffin. And may the best recipe prevail.
A.
Blueberry Muffins, from Gourmet Magazine (via Food Network)
I found this recipe earlier in the week from a basic recipe search on Food Network. It was rated with 4 stars and sounded pretty simple. So I went ahead and made it.
3/4 C butter, softened
1/2 C vanilla sugar
1/2 C sugar
3/4 C milk
1 egg
1 3/4 C flour, sifted
2 1/2 tsp baking powder
1/2 tsp salt
1 1/2 C blueberries (I used frozen)
1-2 tbsp flour (reserved for the blueberries)
- Preheat the oven to 400. Grease or line a muffin tin; set aside.
- Cream the butter and sugar until fluffy. Add in the egg, mixing well, then slowly add in the milk. Blend completely.
- In a separate bowl, mix together the flour, baking powder, and salt. Add to the butter mixture until just blended.
- Toss the blueberries with flour to coat, then fold into the muffin batter.
- Fill the muffin tin to nearly the top nearly to the top. Bake muffins for 20 minutes, or until an inserted toothpick comes out clean. Turn onto a rack to cool.
I found this recipe (as originally written) a real hassle, so I revised it a tiny bit to be less fussy (and added my own spin with the vanilla sugar and more blueberries!). Blending the milk into the butter/sugar was a soupy nightmare, I'm surprised the muffins even turned out as muffins.
The end result, though, is a very sweet, almost cake-like muffin that I thought was a bit sparse in terms of the blueberries. I really like a lot of blueberry in my muffins, otherwise what's the point of a
blueberry muffin? The muffins also fall apart easily which make them a bit hard to eat.
B.
Double Blueberry Muffins, from Gale Gand (via Food Network)
I've had this recipe in my arsenal for a few years now. Always super simple, always delicious. Like the above recipe, it is also rated with 4 stars on Food Network.
1/2 C butter, softened
1 C sugar
2 eggs
1 tsp vanilla
2 tsp baking powder
1/4 tsp salt
2 1/2 C blueberries (I used frozen)
2 C flour
1/2 C milk
1-2 tbsp flour, reserved for blueberries
1 tbsp sugar, reserved for muffin tops
- Preheat oven to 350. Grease or line a muffin tin, set aside.
- Cream butter and sugar until fluffy. Add eggs, one at a time, then vanilla, baking powder, and salt.
- Mash 3/4 C of the blueberries and blend into the batter.
- Add 1 C of the flour, mix well, then add 1/4 C of the milk and mix well. Repeat and mix until just blended.
- Toss the blueberries with flour to coat, then fold gently into the muffin batter.
- Fill the muffin tin with batter, then sprinkle muffin tops with the sugar.
- Bake for 20 minutes, or until an inserted toothpick comes out clean. Let muffins cool in the tin for 20-30 minutes, then turn out onto a rack to cool.
These muffins have a nice blueberry flavor throughout and a nice texture. I enjoy mine as a nice mid-morning snack with tea.
And the winner is...
B! I prefer this more traditional blueberry muffin for its texture, taste, and appearance. Not to mention it is
really easy to make. If I were big on muffins, I'd probably use this recipe as a nice base to experiment with.